i will start this review with a little story about the state of sony, which has dropped quite dramatically from its days in the ’80s. after deciding to get the sony reader and finding out that it is sold out on the sonystyle web site i remembered that a local mall had a sony style store. so i called the store, getting the number from sony’s web site. there i found this description of the store:

the store is located “next to [the] Apple [store]“. ten or twenty years ago the sony style store would have been the marking point for any mall … not anymore.
ok, now to the sony ebook reader. here is a bit of reasoning and background for my decision to buy the sony ebook reader rather than any of the other options out there (i also looked at the kindle, the iLiad reader from iRex, and the cybook from Bookeen). the situation i found myself in was that i bookmarked a ton of stories on the net, but never read them (at least not on the computer). then at work there was a mountain of paper on my desk, a result to make me read documents and web content by printing it out; but once i read something (if i did) i threw away the paper. this i thought was just a huge waste. so i thought in order to read everything i want to read i should get a printer. but i didn’t want to waste even more paper, i wanted to cut back on the amount of paper i use (both at home and in the office). then during a stop over in houston a couple of month ago i saw the sony ebook reader and was intrigued — i could get an ebook reader and read all the stories and documents through that. so i did some research. i was ultimately looking for a device with an e-ink screen and the capability to show basic text from files that i upload and it should be small.
the kindle fell through pretty quickly because it looks horrible (to me), plus while it has more features than the sony reader, i wasn’t really looking for them. i would have taken the annotation feature from it but i didn’t need the wireless part and the keyboard (which makes the device just way too clunky). the iLiad is probably the s-class of ebook readers but again it had way too many features that i defined as nice to have features and was/am not willing to pay $300 more for. plus, it also like the kindle had a larger form factor. the one device that i looked at most was the cybook from bookeen. it has a great form-factor and a decent price. but in the end i went with the sony ebook reader because it was easier available than the cybook, and because the cybook didn’t seem to have anything that i wanted and that the sony device didn’t have.
i have to be honest, if the iLiad would be available in a version that is the size of the sony reader and with the stylus input but without wifi and for about $400 i would have gotten it over the sony reader.
so now i have the sony ebook reader. i have used it for a week now, and i have to say i am pretty happy with my decision. i use it mostly with my macbook (and yes, there is no real software support for apple, but that only matters for the store, if you connect the reader to the macbook it will just show up as an USB drive). i installed the sony connect store software on my girlfriend’s dell and i am glad i don’t have to use it, and that it is not available for the mac. the app it horrible. extremely slow, and the number of books available is not huge. if you want to replace your book purchases with an ebook the sony might not be the best. the kindle is from what i can tell better there. i bought a couple of books that i always wanted to read but didn’t really want to own in paper and i am fine with that. but i will 80% of the time use the device for documents, so if this is not what you are looking for then the sony reader might not be for you.
like all e-ink devices, the screen is great. you can really read for a long time (something i can’t on a computer screen). i like that you can easily increase the front size (i guess i am getting older). there are two things i would like to see improved on the reader
- speed — it can take a long time for a book to load. once a book is loaded it is fine, but the initial loading time can be a bit too long
- navigation — there are just way too many buttons on the device. some of them have duplicate functionality. this was especially bad at the beginning, now i have gotten used to it and it works but i think it could be made way easier
so there is certainly room for improvement, especially around speed, navigation, and mac compatibility, but if you are just looking for a way to read all these online stories and documents that clog your email inbox all day and you want to cut back on printing out tons of paper every year i think the sony ebook reader is a great device. if you want to have tons of content (books, newspapers, magazines), the kindle is probably the devices to get (although i can’t justify the $400 price tag for that device). if you just want to have the device that can do anything then the iLiad is the reader to go with, for everything else there is the sony device.
one more thing, what i really like is the way it feels in your hands. the weight is just right and the built is good, it doesn’t feel cheap but feels solid.
so in the end i think i would give it a B to B+