last monday, may first, there were demonstrations all across the US. to be honest i still don’t really understand what the demonstrations where about. i have two interpretations. one, that they were about making illegal immigrants legal and not to deport them. two, that they were about a reformation about the american immigration laws. the first interpretation seems to me a bit more true than the second since if this was in general about immigration laws, why where 90 to 95% of the demonstrators mexican or latin american (probably the largest group of illegal immigrants)? now, i am an immigrant myself. a legal one. i have a green card i got. it took quite some time to get it, and it wasn’t easy. so here are my thoughts on the current immigration debate:
1. immigration is good, not only for the US but for any country. but immigration has to be managed, because otherwise why have borders? i guess some people might argue that everyone has the right to live everywhere on this earth, but that is just not the case. and i doubt it would help, after all the rich western nations can only support so many people in their current structures with healthcare and other benefits. so i guess this means countries will have borders and will keep managing the inflow of immigrants.
2. there is this view that some of the illegal immigrants are really smart and they should get a chance. well, i have no doubt that a lot of them are smart, but does that mean that all smart people should be able to move here?
3. the problem with the current debate i think is that it is so focused on mexican and latin american immigrants. which i think is wrong. this should be a debate about illegal immigrants and immigrants. and i think the demonstrations are partly to blame for making this about latin american immigrants only.
4. i don’t think that illegal immigrants should receive any benefits. why? well because it is illegal. i don’t think any group of law breakers has ever gone and demonstrated to fight for more rights. and neither should they. it can be up for discussion if a law makes sense but if everybody agrees that it does then it also should be enacted. and i think having a law that makes certain kinds of immigrations illegal does make sense.
5. i don’t think that deportation is the solution to the problem of immigration. i think the solution has to be an economic one. the companies that hire illegal immigrants have to be punished so that they don’t hire any illegal immigrants anymore.
6. immigration to me has two important components. first, it helps to increase the number of smart people to increase innovation. second, help those in dire need and i am speaking here of political asylum seekers. economic need to me is not a main component, there should be a contingent of immigration spots for those but that should be fairly small and randomly provided.
7. while i think a country should not require a standard culture, i think that what is already happening in some parts of the US is not good, and that is creating sub-cultures. english should be the main language and immigrants should be expected to learn it and use it. there is no need for a spanish or chinese version of the national anthem.
8. is immigration fair? no, it isn’t, but there are many things on this planet that are not fair. and i don’t think that by changing immigration alone things will get all better. especially, again, since the debate only focused on mexican and latin american immigration. if this would be about fairness america would have to let in people from all over the world. the problem is that they can usually not just climb a fence, they have to get here by plane or ship.
9. are these demonstrations comparable to the civil rights movement of the 60s? no, i don’t think so. the civil rights movement was about basic human rights, treating people the same. here we are speaking about people who broke the law. and the law is by far not against human rights. it is a basic law used by pretty much every nation on this planet.
there is probably much more to this topic, but these are the main thoughts that i had when i saw the pictures of the demonstrations on tv last week.
these thoughts might upset some people but i hope not.